

NFT
AI-Generated Works Don’t Meet “Authorship” Element for Copyright – Crypto News
For the U.S. Copyright Office (USCO), an AI-generated work does not satisfy the “authorship” requirement of the U.S. Copyright Act.
Last week, a U.S. federal court upheld a previous decision made by the U.S. Copyright Office to rightfully deny copyright protection for any submitted generative AI works in the United States.
Since the beginning of 2023, almost a dozen copyright or similarly related lawsuits have been filed against AI platform services that center around whether or not AI-generated works satisfy the “authorship” element. The majority of what we’ve seen to date has been concerns surrounding training data and the relationship between the data sets it analyzes and the outputs it generates.
IP Watchdog’s Franklin Graves listed nine cases that currently focus on these issues, ranging from Getty Images (US) and Stability AI to OpenAI, Meta, and Alphabet.
Earlier this month, The New York Times updated its Terms of Service to restrict its content from being used to train any machine learning system or AI algorithm.
Unfortunately, a good chunk of the material that OpenAI uses in its training datasets comes from previously established copyrighted works – without consent, credit, and compensating the author.
Dr. Stephen Thaler’s Battle With the USCO
Last week’s Order from the Court stems from Dr. Thaler’s initial June 2022 complaint against the USCO, where he argues that an AI-generated work should be afforded copyright protection.
The work in question is an AI-generated work called “A Recent Entrance to Paradise,” which was the output of Dr. Thaler’s AI system, “Creativity Machine.”
In January, he filed a motion for summary judgment, arguing that pursuant to the U.S. Copyright Act, an individual should be allowed to register for copyright protection in a creative work that is generated by artificial intelligence.
In his motion for summary judgment, Dr. Thaler asked for the U.S. District Court to issue an order that would require the USCO to set aside the Review Board’s February 2022 decision upholding the USCO’s previous stances in denying copyright registration for his work – and instead, reexamine his initial copyright registration application for the work.
He put forth four arguments to support his position:
- The plain language of the U.S. Copyright Act as it currently reads, allows for copyright protection of AI-generated works similar to protections granted to non-human entities and corporations, satisfying the “authorship” requirement.
- Since the U.S. Supreme Court’s (SCOTUS) decision in the 1800 case of Burrow-Giles Lithographic Co. v. Sarony, which the Review Board stated in its opinion letter, there is a lack of knowledge and subsequently, a lack of case law that supports the USCO’s position.
- The courts should apply the Turing Test, which was developed in 1950 by Alan Turing, whereby the courts should work to answer the question of “whether a machine can make something indistinguishable from a person for purposes of copyright protection?” To support this, he referenced two cases from the Ninth Circuit – a case involving a book partially created by spiritual beings (Urantia Foundation v. Maaherra) and the monkey selfie case (Naruto v. Slater).
- The AI-generated work could be classified as a “work-for-hire.” He emphasized that while an AI is not an “employee” or an “independent contractor” under the doctrine in terms of having the ability to execute a contract, AI “functionally behaves” and as such, should be granted a similar status.
The USCO didn’t bite on any of the arguments, filing its motion for summary judgment that, if granted, would automatically dismiss the case with respect to the specific issues presented, in favor of the USCO.
Dr. Thaler filed his response in March, arguing that due to our technological advances, the current provisions of both the U.S. Copyright Act and the U.S. Constitution should be interpreted with outside materials, including anything prior to its legislation that can better speak to the issue at hand. He specifically points out that “this is perhaps the paradigmatic case of technological evolution” that requires this type of statutory interpretation.
Where We Are Right Now
The biggest concern right now, which IPWatchdog recognizes, is that the USCO currently relies on an “honor system” for disclosing whether a work was generated by an AI software or a similarly related algorithm.
This was something Dr. Thaler highlighted in his initial complaint – if he had submitted the same AI-generated work, listing his company as the author, the USCO would never have known and most likely have granted his company copyright protection. However, the Review Board does have criminal penalties for anyone who “knowingly makes a false representation of a material fact” in their copyright registration application.
The reality is we are watching the formation of legal precedent surrounding copyright protection (and patent protection) for AI-generated works and the relationship between the materials its datasets are trained on and the outputs these machines and algorithms are spitting out.
Graves, who went deeper into the way forward, laid out his question on where we are on this “creation-generation spectrum” that draws the line between whether a work is eligible for copyright registration or not.
And that brings us further down the rabbit hole of the conundrum we currently are facing with digital art and NFTs right now.
-
others1 week ago
Will Ethereum Price Rally to $3,200 as Wall Street Pivots from BTC to ETH – Crypto News
-
others7 days ago
Skies are clearing for Delta as stock soars 13% on earnings beat – Crypto News
-
others7 days ago
Skies are clearing for Delta as stock soars 13% on earnings beat – Crypto News
-
Blockchain1 week ago
Insomnia Labs Debuts Stablecoin Credit Platform for Creators – Crypto News
-
Blockchain1 week ago
Ant Group Eyes USDC Integration Circle’s: Report – Crypto News
-
Blockchain1 week ago
EU Questions Robinhood About OpenAI and SpaceX Stock Tokens – Crypto News
-
others1 week ago
Appropriate to have cautious gradual stance on easing – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency1 week ago
Tornado Cash Judge Won’t Let One Case Be Mentioned in Roman Storm’s Trial: Here’s Why – Crypto News
-
others1 week ago
USD/CAD trades with positive bias below 1.3700; looks to FOMC minutes for fresh impetus – Crypto News
-
Blockchain1 week ago
Kraken and Backed Expand Tokenized Equities to BNB Chain – Crypto News
-
Business1 week ago
Did Ripple Really Win XRP Lawsuit Despite $125M Fine? Lawyer Fires Back at CEO – Crypto News
-
others1 week ago
EUR/GBP posts modest gain above 0.8600 ahead of German inflation data – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency7 days ago
Bitcoin Breaks New Record at $111K, What’s Fueling the $120K Price Target? – Crypto News
-
Technology7 days ago
XRP Eyes $3 Breakout Amid Rising BlackRock ETF Speculation – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency1 week ago
On thinking ahead when markets get murky – Crypto News
-
Technology1 week ago
Solana Meme Coin PNUT Rallies 10% Amid Elon Musk’s Statement – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency1 week ago
Is ETH Finally Ready to Shoot For $3K? (Ethereum Price Analysis) – Crypto News
-
Blockchain1 week ago
XRP Rally Possible If Senate Web3 Crypto Summit Goes Well – Crypto News
-
Blockchain1 week ago
Ethereum Bulls Roar — $3K Beckons After 5% Spike – Crypto News
-
Technology1 week ago
VC Firm Ego Death Capital Closes $100M Funding to Back Bitcoin-Based Projects – Crypto News
-
others1 week ago
NovaEx Launches with a Security-First Crypto Trading Platform Offering Deep Liquidity and Institutional-Grade Infrastructure – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency1 week ago
XRP price forecast as coins surges 2.19% to $2.33 – Crypto News
-
others1 week ago
Anthony Scaramucci Says $180,000 Bitcoin Price Explosion Possible As BTC ‘Supremacy’ Creeps Up – Here’s His Timeline – Crypto News
-
Blockchain7 days ago
SUI Chart Pattern Confirmation Sets $3.89 Price Target – Crypto News
-
Technology7 days ago
Breaking: SharpLink Purchases 10,000 ETH from Ethereum Foundation, SBET Stock Up 7% – Crypto News
-
others6 days ago
EUR/GBP climbs as weak UK data fuels BoE rate cut speculation – Crypto News
-
Blockchain6 days ago
Bitcoin Hits All-Time High as Crypto Legislation Votes Near – Crypto News
-
Business6 days ago
PENGU Rallies Over 20% Amid Coinbase’s Pudgy Penguins PFP Frenzy – Crypto News
-
Blockchain4 days ago
Robinhood Dealing With Fallout of Tokenized Equities Offering – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency1 week ago
XRP could rally higher on steady capital inflow; check forecast – Crypto News
-
Blockchain1 week ago
Vitalik Buterin Backs Copyleft Licensing for Fairer Crypto – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency1 week ago
Bulls In Control But Resistance Persists at $2.30. What Next? – Crypto News
-
Technology1 week ago
GameSquare Stock Shoots 58% After Revealing $100 Million Ethereum Treasury Strategy – Crypto News
-
others1 week ago
Australian Dollar remains stronger due to persistent inflation risks, FOMC Minutes eyed – Crypto News
-
others1 week ago
US Dollar Resurgence May Be Around the Corner, According to Barclays Currency Strategist – Here’s Why: Report – Crypto News
-
others1 week ago
Trump Jr. Backed Thumzup Media To Invest In ETH, XRP, SOL, DOGE And LTC – Crypto News
-
Technology1 week ago
Google’s worst nightmare? OpenAI’s new AI web browser is coming soon to challenge Chrome – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency1 week ago
Bitcoin Hits Record Peak. How High Can It Surge in 2025? – Crypto News
-
Blockchain1 week ago
Binance Founder Backs BNB Treasury Company Aiming For US IPO – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency1 week ago
Tokenized Securities Are Still Securities, US SEC Warns Robinhood, Kraken – Crypto News
-
Technology1 week ago
10 Smartchoice tablets from top brands, curated for everyday use, up to 45% off before Amazon Prime Day Sale – Crypto News
-
Blockchain1 week ago
Australia Banks Join Digital Currency Trial for Tokenized Assets – Crypto News
-
others1 week ago
China’s Ant Group With 1.4B Users Taps Circle to Integrate USDC – Crypto News
-
Metaverse1 week ago
How Brands Can Deepen Customer Connections in the Metaverse – Crypto News
-
Technology7 days ago
Perplexity launches Comet, an AI-powered browser to challenge Google Chrome; OpenAI expected to enter the space soon – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency7 days ago
Bitcoin Breaks New Record at $111K, What’s Fueling the $120K Price Target? – Crypto News
-
others7 days ago
$687,220,000 in Bitcoin Shorts Liquidated in Just One Hour As BTC Explodes To $116,000 – Crypto News
-
Business6 days ago
S&P Global Downgrades Saks Global’s Credit Rating – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency3 days ago
Whale Sells $407K TRUMP, Loses $1.37M in Exit – Crypto News
-
others1 week ago
Trader Says Matter of Time Before Crypto Breaks to New All-Time Highs, Updates Outlook on Bitcoin, Ethereum and One Other Altcoin – Crypto News