 
									 
																		
									
									
								Blockchain
The SEC shook Kraken down for $30M, but it doesn’t mean they had a case – Crypto News
The settlement between Kraken (Payward Ventures) and the United States Securities and Exchange Commission set off alarm bells in the crypto community this month. Apparently, Kraken — one of the most compliance-minded crypto exchanges in existence — decided to buy its peace rather than fight with the SEC for years over whether it was offering unregistered “securities” through its staking program. The nature of the settlement is that Kraken neither admitted nor denied the SEC’s allegations, and the existence of the settlement, technically speaking, cannot be used as legal precedent for any argument either side of the issue might present.
That said, the settlement matters, as it will clearly chill crypto staking in the United States. As SEC Chairman Gary Gensler said, “Whether it’s through staking-as-a-service, lending, or other means, crypto intermediaries, when offering investment contracts in exchange for investors’ tokens, need to provide the proper disclosures and safeguards required by our securities laws.” Gensler casts a wide net, indeed, for what the SEC considers to be “investment contracts,” and running staking out of business was perhaps precisely what he had in mind.
Related: Expect the SEC to use its Kraken playbook against staking protocols
That the SEC was successful in pressuring Kraken out of $30 million does not, however, make the agency’s position legally or logically correct. As a preliminary matter, “staking” and “lending” are totally different things. Staking is the process by which one pledges one’s coins or tokens to a proof-of-stake blockchain, either directly or by delegating one’s coins to a third party, for the purpose of securing the network. Stakers are the ones through whom the blockchain’s consensus mechanism operates, as they “vote” on which blocks will be added to the chain. The process is algorithmic, and the reward is automatic when one’s position is electronically “selected” as the validator for a given block.
Settlements are not law. They’re a decision that the economics of settling are better than fighting, no more.
The SEC thinks staking-as-a-service is a security. Kraken didn’t admit or deny either way.
It may be a tough question, but the SEC hasn’t answered it either way today.
— Jake Chervinsky (@jchervinsky) February 9, 2023
Stakers don’t necessarily know who the other stakers are, nor do they need to know, as the fate of one’s stake is dependent only on following the rules of that blockchain as to “liveness” (availability) and other technical considerations. There are risks of “slashing” (losing your coins) for bad behavior or unavailability, but again, these are algorithmic remedies doled out automatically according to transparent rules built into the code. Put simply, in staking, it’s between you and the blockchain, not you and the intermediary.
Lending, in contrast, invokes the entrepreneurial and managerial skill (or lack thereof) of the people to whom you lend. This is a distinctly human enterprise. One does not necessarily know what the borrower is doing with the money; one simply hopes to get it back with a return. This counterparty risk is in part what the securities laws are intended to address. In lending, the relationship is between the lender and the borrower, a relationship that can take all kinds of unexpected turns.
Related: Kraken staking ban is another nail in crypto’s coffin — and that’s a good thing
The reasons why staking arrangements are not “investment contracts” (and thereby “securities”) were stated eloquently by Coinbase chief legal officer Paul Grewal in a blog post. Put simply, merely serving as an intermediary does not render the underlying economic relationship an “investment contract.” Yet the SEC here doesn’t seem to want to entertain the differences between service providers and counterparties.
It is true that third parties, such as Kraken, serve a custodial role in the staking relationship — that is, they may hold the private keys to the particular coins the client intended to stake. However, serving as a custodian of a fungible asset, especially where such a custodian holds collateral on a 1:1 basis to back every customer account, is a discreet service.
There is nothing to suggest that Kraken, Coinbase or any other staking-as-a-service provider, otherwise uses human judgment, intuition, grit or any other hallmark of one’s entrepreneurial or managerial ability, to advance or inhibit the staker’s purpose. One’s reward does not improve or decline based on how the intermediary performs. There should be (and are) rules and regulations for how custodians function, but possession does not, by itself, make a security.
Ari Good is an attorney whose clients include payments companies, cryptocurrency exchanges and token issuers. His practice areas focus on tax, securities and financial services compliance matters. He received his juris doctor from the DePaul University College of Law in 1997, his Master of Laws in taxation from the University of Florida in 2005, and is currently a candidate for the Executive Master of Laws in securities and financial regulation from the Georgetown University Law Center.
This article is for general information purposes and is not intended to be and should not be taken as legal or investment advice. The views, thoughts, and opinions expressed here are the author’s alone and do not necessarily reflect or represent the views and opinions of Cointelegraph.
- 
																Business1 week agoSolana Price Eyes $240 Recovery as Gemini Launches SOL-Reward Credit Card – Crypto News 
- 
																Technology1 week agoBlockchain for Good Alliance and UNDP AltFinLab Launch Blockchain Impact Forum – Crypto News 
- 
																Technology1 week agoBlockchain for Good Alliance and UNDP AltFinLab Launch Blockchain Impact Forum – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Blockchain1 week ago Blockchain1 week agoTokenized Deposits for Payments, Treasury – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Technology1 week ago Technology1 week agoLayerZero outlook: ZRO price on the edge ahead of $43M token unlock – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Blockchain1 week ago Blockchain1 week agoBitcoin Weekly RSI Points To More Upside, But Can the Bulls Defend $107,000? – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Metaverse1 week ago Metaverse1 week agoTech layoffs: From Meta, Amazon to Google — these IT majors have cut AI related jobs – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Technology1 week ago Technology1 week agoEthereum’s Vitalik Buterin applauds Polygon for pioneering ZK technology – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Blockchain1 week ago Blockchain1 week agoXRP Whales Flood Binance With Massive Deposits – Selling Pressure Mounts – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Technology1 week ago Technology1 week agoThinking of cancelling HBO Max? Subscription prices just went up – Here’s what you need to know – Crypto News 
- 
																Technology1 week agoFed’s Payments Conference: Waller Floats ‘Payment Account’ Framework to Support Crypto Innovation – Crypto News 
- 
																Technology1 week agoProShares Files for Index Crypto ETF Tracking Bitcoin, Ethereum, XRP, and Solana – Crypto News 
- 
																Business1 week agoXRP Price Classical Pattern Points to a Rebound as XRPR ETF Hits $100M Milestone – Crypto News 
- 
																Technology1 week ago$1.68 Trillion T. Rowe Price Files for First Active Crypto ETF Holding BTC, ETH, SOL, and XRP – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Cryptocurrency1 week ago Cryptocurrency1 week agoCrypto update: Bitcoin and Ethereum are stable as market’s focus shifts to US inflation data – Crypto News 
- 
																	   others1 week ago others1 week agoAustralian Dollar remains subdued as US Dollar corrects upwards – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Cryptocurrency1 week ago Cryptocurrency1 week agoExclusive: YZi Labs leads $25M round for Sign – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Technology1 week ago Technology1 week agoOnePlus 15R full specifications leaked ahead of launch: here’s what to expect – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Cryptocurrency1 week ago Cryptocurrency1 week agoStreamer Sam Pepper Banned From Pump.fun, Kick After Injuring Girl With Firework Stunt – Crypto News 
- 
																Business1 week agoChainlink Price Eyes $27 Rebound as Whales Accumulate 54M LINK – Crypto News 
- 
																	   De-fi1 week ago De-fi1 week agoKDA Plummets as Kadena Organization Shuts Down Operations – Crypto News 
- 
																others1 week agoJapan Adjusted Merchandise Trade Balance down to ¥-314.3B in September from previous ¥-150.1B – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Technology1 week ago Technology1 week agoChatGPT down: Thousands of users unable to access AI chatbot, OpenAI says it is working on a fix – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Metaverse1 week ago Metaverse1 week agoBezos fund believes AI can save the planet. Nvidia, Google are all-in. – Crypto News 
- 
																Cryptocurrency1 week agoRobinhood Lists HYPE As Hyperliquid Flips Aster, Lighter In Perp DEX Volume – Crypto News 
- 
																Cryptocurrency6 days agoXRP News: Ripple Unveils ‘Ripple Prime’ After Closing $1.25B Hidden Road Deal – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Cryptocurrency6 days ago Cryptocurrency6 days agoTrump plans to pick Michael Selig to lead CFTC: Report – Crypto News 
- 
																Business5 days agoWhite House Crypto Czar Backs Michael Selig as ‘Excellent Choice’ To Lead CFTC – Crypto News 
- 
																others5 days agoJPY soft and underperforming G10 in quiet trade – Scotiabank – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Cryptocurrency4 days ago Cryptocurrency4 days agoUSDJPY Forecast: The Dollar’s Winning Streak Why New Highs Could Be At Hand – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Blockchain1 week ago Blockchain1 week agoHere’s What Happens To The Ethereum Price If Bullish Momentum Holds – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Technology1 week ago Technology1 week agoSamsung set to launch ‘Project Moohan’, an Android XR device to rival Apple Vision Pro: Where to watch livestream – Crypto News 
- 
																Business1 week agoCrypto Czar David Sacks to Meet Senate Republicans In Bid To Advance Market Structure Bill – Crypto News 
- 
																others1 week agoVeteran Trader Peter Brandt Says “MSTR Could Go Underwater” If Bitcoin Repeats 1977 Soybean Crash – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Blockchain1 week ago Blockchain1 week agoHere’s Why The Shiba Inu Price Could Bottom And Rise Another 40% – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Technology1 week ago Technology1 week agoSundar Pichai hails ‘verifiable’ quantum computing breakthrough as Google’s Willow surpasses ability of supercomputers – Crypto News 
- 
																Business1 week agoBreaking: Trump To Meet China’s President On October 30, Bitcoin Bounces – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Blockchain6 days ago Blockchain6 days agoAfrica Countries Pass Crypto Laws to Attract Industry – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Blockchain5 days ago Blockchain5 days agoISM Data Hints Bitcoin Cycle Could Last Longer Than Usual – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Blockchain5 days ago Blockchain5 days agoBinance Stablecoin Outflow On A Steady Rise — What This Means For The Market – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Blockchain5 days ago Blockchain5 days agoEthereum Rebounds From Bull Market Support: Can It Conquer The ‘Golden Pocket’ Next? – Crypto News 
- 
																others5 days agoPlatinum price recovers from setback – Commerzbank – Crypto News 
- 
																	   De-fi4 days ago De-fi4 days agoNearly Half of US Retail Crypto Holders Haven’t Earned Yield: MoreMarkets – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Technology4 days ago Technology4 days agoSurvival instinct? New study says some leading AI models won’t let themselves be shut down – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Blockchain4 days ago Blockchain4 days agoXRP Price Gains Traction — Buyers Pile In Ahead Of Key Technical Breakout – Crypto News 
- 
																Business1 week agoTrump Advisor Hints US Government Shutdown Could End This Week, Opening Door for XRP ETF Ruling – Crypto News 
- 
																others1 week agoSolana News: Gemini Launches SOL Edition Credit Card Following XRP Card Success – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Cryptocurrency1 week ago Cryptocurrency1 week agoCrypto traders locked out as AWS outage cripples Coinbase and Robinhood – Crypto News 
- 
																Business1 week agoAster Outpaces Lighter in Perp DEX Rankings as Wintermute Buys the Dip After Previous Dump – Crypto News 
- 
																	   Blockchain1 week ago Blockchain1 week ago$11B Bitcoin Whale Shorts Bitcoin for $235M, Nets $200M In Market Crash – Crypto News 

 
									 
																	 
									 
																	 
									 
																	 
									 
																	 
									 
																	 
									 
																	 
									 
																	 
									