

Metaverse
What will humans do if technology solves everything? – Crypto News
That is one question considered in a new publication by Nick Bostrom, a philosopher at the University of Oxford, whose last book argued that humanity faced a one-in-six chance of being wiped out in the next 100 years, perhaps owing to the development of dangerous forms of artificial intelligence (AI). In Mr Bostrom’s latest book, “Deep Utopia”, he considers a rather different outcome. What happens if AI goes extraordinarily well? Under one scenario Mr Bostrom contemplates, the technology progresses to the point at which it can do all economically valuable work at near-zero cost. Under a yet more radical scenario, even tasks that you might think would be reserved for humans, such as parenting, can be done better by AI. This may sound more dystopian than utopian, but Mr Bostrom argues otherwise.
Start with the first scenario, which Mr Bostrom labels a “post-scarcity” utopia. In such a world, the need for work would be reduced. Almost a century ago John Maynard Keynes wrote an essay entitled “Economic Possibilities for Our Grandchildren”, which predicted that 100 years into the future his wealthy descendants would need to work for only 15 hours a week. This has not quite come to pass, but working time has fallen greatly. In the rich world average weekly working hours have dropped from more than 60 in the late 19th century to fewer than 40 today. The typical American spends a third of their waking hours on leisure activities and sports. In the future, they may wish to spend their time on things beyond humanity’s current conception. As Mr Bostrom writes, when aided by powerful tech, “the space of possible-for-us experiences extends far beyond those that are accessible to us with our present unoptimised brains.”
Yet Mr Bostrom’s label of a “post-scarcity” utopia might be slightly misleading: the economic explosion caused by superintelligence would still be limited by physical resources, most notably land. Although space exploration may hugely increase the building space available, it will not make it infinite. There are also intermediate worlds where humans develop powerful new forms of intelligence, but do not become space-faring. In such worlds, wealth may be fantastic, but lots of it could be absorbed by housing—much as is the case in rich countries today.
“Positional goods”, which boost the status of their owners, are also still likely to exist and are, by their nature, scarce. Even if AIs surpass humans in art, intellect, music and sport, humans will probably continue to derive value from surpassing their fellow humans, for example by having tickets to the hottest events. In 1977 Fred Hirsch, an economist, argued in “The Social Limits to Growth” that, as wealth increases, a greater fraction of human desire consists of positional goods. Time spent competing goes up, the price of such goods increases and so their share of GDP rises. This pattern may continue in an AI utopia.
Mr Bostrom notes some types of competition are a failure of co-ordination: if everyone agrees to stop competing, they would have time for other, better things, which could further boost growth. Yet some types of competition, such as sport, have intrinsic value, and are worth preserving. (Humans may also have nothing better to do.) Interest in chess has grown since IBM’s Deep Blue first defeated Garry Kasparov, then world champion, in 1997. An entire industry has emerged around e-sports, where computers can comfortably defeat humans. Their revenues are expected to grow at a 20% annual rate over the next decade, reaching nearly $11bn by 2032. Several groups in society today give us a sense of how future humans might spend their time. Aristocrats and bohemians enjoy the arts. Monastics live within themselves. Athletes spend their lives on sport. The retired dabble in all these pursuits.
Everyone’s early retirement
Won’t tasks such as parenting remain the refuge of humans? Mr Bostrom is not so sure. He argues that beyond the post-scarcity world lies a “post-instrumental” one, in which AIs would become superhuman at child care, too. Keynes himself wrote that “there is no country and no people, I think, who can look forward to the age of leisure and of abundance without a dread. For we have been trained too long to strive and not to enjoy…To judge from the behaviour and the achievements of the wealthy classes today in any quarter of the world, the outlook is very depressing!” The Bible puts it more succinctly: “idle hands are the devil’s workshop.”
These dynamics suggest a “paradox of progress”. Although most humans want a better world, if tech becomes too advanced, they may lose purpose. Mr Bostrom argues that most people would still enjoy activities that have intrinsic value, such as eating tasty food. Utopians, believing life had become too easy, might decide to challenge themselves, perhaps by colonising a new planet to try to re-engineer civilisation from scratch. At some point, however, even such adventures might cease to feel worthwhile. It is an open question how long humans would be happy hopping between passions, as Peer does in “Permutation City”. Economists have long believed that humans have “unlimited wants and desires”, suggesting there are endless variations on things people would like to consume. With the arrival of an AI utopia, this would be put to the test. Quite a lot would ride on the result.
For more expert analysis of the biggest stories in economics, finance and markets, sign up to Money Talks, our weekly subscriber-only newsletter.
© 2024, The Economist Newspaper Limited. All rights reserved. From The Economist, published under licence. The original content can be found on www.economist.com
Milestone Alert!
Livemint tops charts as the fastest growing news website in the world 🌏 Click here to know more.
3.6 Crore Indians visited in a single day choosing us as India’s undisputed platform for General Election Results. Explore the latest updates here!
Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.
Published: 09 Jun 2024, 07:04 PM IST
-
others7 days ago
Here’s What Bitcoin Needs To Do To Confirm Bullish Breakout, According to Trader Who Nailed 2024 BTC Correction – Crypto News
-
Blockchain7 days ago
XRP MVRV Ratio Dips Below The 200-Day MA – Trend Shift Underway? – Crypto News
-
others6 days ago
Bybit Shuts Down Its NFT Marketplace As Crypto Sector Struggles To Recover – Crypto News
-
Technology1 week ago
How to generate Ghibli-style AI portraits using Grok 3 — no ChatGPT subscription needed – Crypto News
-
Technology1 week ago
How to generate Ghibli-style AI portraits using Grok 3 — no ChatGPT subscription needed – Crypto News
-
Business7 days ago
Can Pi Coin Price Hit $1 Soon? – Crypto News
-
others7 days ago
Here’s What Bitcoin Needs To Do To Confirm Bullish Breakout, According to Trader Who Nailed 2024 BTC Correction – Crypto News
-
others7 days ago
Here’s What Bitcoin Needs To Do To Confirm Bullish Breakout, According to Trader Who Nailed 2024 BTC Correction – Crypto News
-
others7 days ago
XRP and Three Other Altcoins Could Witness Another Sell-Off Event, According to Crypto Strategist – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency6 days ago
Sony Singapore Now Lets Shoppers Pay in USDC Through Crypto.com – Crypto News
-
Blockchain6 days ago
Dogecoin Breaking These Levels Could Be The Catalyst For Next Bull Run, Analyst Says – Crypto News
-
Business1 week ago
XRP, BTC, ETH Price Prediction As Inflation Data Sparks Downturn in U.S. Stocks – Crypto News
-
Blockchain7 days ago
zkLend hacker claims losing stolen ETH to Tornado Cash phishing site – Crypto News
-
others7 days ago
Gold extends bullish trend amid rising trade tensions; fresh record high and counting – Crypto News
-
Blockchain7 days ago
SpaceX flight bankrolled by crypto investor launches first manned polar orbit – Crypto News
-
Blockchain7 days ago
Will Bitcoin Downtrend Continue? This Metric Suggests Yes – Crypto News
-
Blockchain7 days ago
Binance ends Tether USDT trading in Europe to comply with MiCA rules – Crypto News
-
Blockchain7 days ago
Binance ends Tether USDT trading in Europe to comply with MiCA rules – Crypto News
-
Technology6 days ago
XRP Price Predicted to Reach $10 in April if US Congress Stablecoin Bill Promotes Ripple’s RLUSD – Crypto News
-
Business6 days ago
XRP Price Predicted to Reach $10 in April if US Congress Stablecoin Bill Promotes Ripple’s RLUSD – Crypto News
-
Technology6 days ago
Apple Intelligence debuts on Vision Pro with visionOS 2.4 update: AI-powered features, spatial content and more – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency6 days ago
US equities slip after job openings disappointment – Crypto News
-
others6 days ago
Will BNB Price Rally to ATH After VanEck BNB ETF Filing? – Crypto News
-
others6 days ago
Pound Sterling consolidates against US Dollar ahead of Trump’s tariffs announcement – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency6 days ago
FLOKI price poised for 20% rally, Here’s why – Crypto News
-
others6 days ago
PENDLE Price Jumps 8% Today Amid Huge Whale Accumulation – Crypto News
-
others6 days ago
Fundstrat’s Tom Lee Calls for Imminent Stock Market Reversal, Says US Has the ‘Right Pieces’ for a Bottom – Crypto News
-
Technology6 days ago
European regulators warn of financial risks from US crypto integration – Crypto News
-
Business1 week ago
Builder.ai Announces Third-Party Audit After Allegations – Crypto News
-
Technology7 days ago
Over 60 pc broadband, fiber, DSL users surveyed flag problems with connection: LocalCircles poll – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency7 days ago
Tether Boosts Bitcoin Holdings By 8,888 BTC In Q1 2025 – Crypto News
-
others7 days ago
Austria Unemployment fell from previous 347.4K to 316.3K in March – Crypto News
-
Blockchain7 days ago
Hayes Predicts $250,000 Bitcoin As Fed Caves To QE Pressure – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency7 days ago
XRP, DOGE Shoot up as BTC Price Reclaims $84K Level (Market Watch) – Crypto News
-
Technology7 days ago
Best washing machines under ₹10000 in April 2025 to boost your laundry routine without overspending – Crypto News
-
Blockchain7 days ago
Analyst Calls Dogecoin Chart A ‘Beauty’ As Key Indicators Align – Crypto News
-
Blockchain6 days ago
Bitcoin Price Bounces Back—Can It Finally Break Resistance? – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency6 days ago
US equities slip after job openings disappointment – Crypto News
-
Blockchain6 days ago
Several Altcoins Crash Up To 50% On Binance, What’s Going On? – Crypto News
-
Business6 days ago
What to Expect From XRP Price as Trump’s ‘Liberation Day’ Tariffs Go Into Effect Today – Crypto News
-
Metaverse1 week ago
The Tools of Tomorrow: What Lies Ahead with the AI Revolution – Crypto News
-
Business1 week ago
MicroStrategy Acquires 22,048 Bitcoin For $1.92 Billion – Crypto News
-
Business1 week ago
ChatGPT To Launch Next Big Model, New Studio Ghibli Ahead? – Crypto News
-
others7 days ago
Will the RBA hint at further interest rate hikes at its policy meeting? – Crypto News
-
Technology7 days ago
Bumper discounts in Amazon Gaming Fest! Up to 70% off on gaming laptops, monitors, vlog cameras and more – Crypto News
-
Technology7 days ago
Whale Offloads ETH at Loss, But Experts Predict Ethereum Price Rally Amid April Macroeconomic Events – Crypto News
-
Technology7 days ago
SBI down: Mobile banking, ATMs and more affected; here’s what the bank said… – Crypto News
-
Cryptocurrency7 days ago
Crypto Game ‘Blade of God X’ Accused of Mismanagement by Former Exec – Crypto News
-
others7 days ago
GBP/USD could stretch lower if 1.2900 support fails – Crypto News
-
others7 days ago
Goldman Sachs Raises Chance of Recession in a Year to 35%, Says Trump Tariffs To Cause Inflation Spike: Report – Crypto News